We owe Skyrim’s beloved Stealth Archer to one of the designers of an all-time classic PC stealth game, who wrote Todd Howard ‘a big document of stealth in 20 different games’
I love stealth games, and I love playing a sneaky guy in bigger RPGs: Fallout, The Elder Scrolls, Cyberpunk. You best believe that, when given the option, I’m crouch walking for 80 hours straight. I’m not alone in that preference either: The Stealth Archer in Skyrim, which plays exactly how it sounds, is a memetic, fan-favorite playstyle in Bethesda’s smash hit RPG, with guides, analysis, and love letters galore on YouTube and Reddit.
Being obsessed with stealth in games, particularly Bethesda RPGs, I’ve always wondered about the Pagliarulo Connection: Bethesda’s design director, who has contributed to all of the studio’s games since Oblivion, got his development start at Looking Glass Studios, the legendary ’90s developer of Ultima Underworld, System Shock, and Thief.
The Boston-based Looking Glass (initially Blue Sky Productions) was founded by Origin Systems (Ultima, Wing Commander) developer Paul Neurath, and drew on MIT graduates for its first staff members—something that helps explain its games’ cerebral sensibilities and exacting simulations. In another timeline, id cofounder John Romero might have helped start Looking Glass, while Pagliarulo, before becoming a developer, was editor of gaming website Adrenaline Vault.
“Thief was the first game that I played with headphones on in a dark room. I love that game so much, and so it was impossible for me not to bring that stuff over,” Pagliarulo said. “In fact, one of the first things I did when I was hired here, Todd asked me, ‘Hey, what do you think about the stealth in our games and stuff? Can you write something up?’
“So I did an analysis. I wrote up a big document of stealth in 20 different games, how they compared, and what we could do for stealth in Oblivion.”
Speaking as a massive loser, I would love to read that stealth games analysis, which Pagliarulo said might still be tucked away in his office somewhere. One of the 20 games in question, according to Pagliarulo, was Hidden and Dangerous, a 1999 tactical shooter where you parachute behind German lines in 1941 to get up to assorted military hijinks and criminal mischief. It’s actually still available for purchase on both Steam and GOG.
While Skyrim is where the Stealth Archer blew up, and Morrowind and Daggerfall had stealth systems, Oblivion is where the playstyle started being fun. The 2006 RPG had consistent sound and line of sight rules the player could account for, clear indication of whether you were hidden or not, as well as stealth-focused Thieves Guild and Dark Brotherhood quests that took advantage of the new system.
“The thing is, Thief is a deep [game], a lot of depth, not a lot of width. It focuses on one thing: It’s a stealth simulation.” Pagliarulo said of the distinction between Thief and The Elder Scrolls. “Bethesda’s games have been accused of being ‘an inch deep and a mile wide’—which I think is an insult, honestly, because I think there’s a lot of depth there—but we do provide a lot of different systems.
“Because we’re a simulation, we do offer crime and stealth, and a lot of games don’t offer that, so we were like, how do we get it as good as it can be, but still have time to do all these other systems and stuff. So it’s that balancing act.”
That does get at the heart of what makes sneaking in Bethesda games special, even compared to more intricate stealth sims: It’s fun to have a choice, and to define the identity of your Orc or Dark Elf or whoever in opposition to the dozens of other characters they could have been. And it’s a balm to my soul to see the DNA of the long-departed and never financially successful Looking Glass end up in some of the most popular videogames of all time.
“I’m really happy with where we’ve landed on [stealth gameplay] over the years,” Pagliarulo concluded. “And I mean, look at the Stealth Archer—the Stealth Archer in Skyrim is proof of that. I think it’s just so rewarding to see those characters. So, yeah, the lessons I learned [at Looking Glass] have been with me my whole life, 100%.”
